| Franchise |
QB | RB | WR | TE | PK | Def |
| Bull..Titletown | Bulger, M Cutler, J Rosenfels, S | Foster, D Grant, R Jones, T Morris, M | Burleson, N Holt, T Johnson, A Moss, S | Heap, T Scheffler, T | Brown, K | Bears, C Giants, N |
| Arizona Firestorm | Edwards, T Palmer, C Schaub, M | Dayne, R Fargas, J Parker, W Williams, D | Boldin, A Fitzgerald, L Henry, C Johnson, B Johnson, C | Winslow, K | Longwell, R | Cowboys, D Jaguars, J |
| Chili Crashers | Brady, T Cassel, M Manning, E | Dunn, W Faulk, K Graham, E Watson, K | Chambers, C Evans, L Gaffney, J Moss, R Stallworth, D Toomer, A | Daniels, O | Hanson, J | Steelers, P |
| Hank the Tank | Clemens, K Garcia, J Garrard, D McNabb, D | Betts, L Chatman, J Jackson, F Peterson, A Portis, C Westbrook, B | Berrian, B Galloway, J Wayne, R | Lee, D | Gould, R | Seahawks, S |
| Blazing Gunz | Collins, T Hasselbeck, M Kitna, J | Pittman, M Smith, M Taylor, C Toefield, L | Bowe, D Bruce, I Curtis, K McDonald, S Smith, S | Clark, D Clark, D | Bironas, R | Colts, I |
| RF Squirrels Gone Wild | Jackson, T Redman, C Romo, T | Lewis, J Tomlinson, L Turner, M Walker, D | Curry, R Furrey, M Gage, J Gonzalez, A Walker, J Williams, R | Lewis, M | Folk, N | Packers, G |
| Shortcake Delight | Croyle, B Lemon, C Pennington, C Roethlisberger, B | Addai, J Jones-Drew, M Keith, K Peterson, A Young, S | Branch, D Edwards, B Houshmandzadeh, T Welker, W | Witten, J | Kaeding, N | Patriots, N |
| Captain Bitchslap | Anderson, D Favre, B Grossman, R | James, E Johnson, R Lynch, M Maroney, L Thomas, A | Cotchery, J Driver, D Harrison, M Jennings, G Ward, H | Davis, V | Vinatieri, A | Buccaneers, T |
| Moo Juice | Manning, P Wallace, S | Benson, C Buckhalter, C Jacobs, B Norwood, J | Holmes, S Jackson, V Johnson, C Jones, J Jurevicius, J Porter, J | Miller, H | Gostkowski, S Rackers, N | Redskins, W |
| Thunder | Campbell, J Dilfer, T Huard, D | Alexander, S Henry, C Johnson, L Taylor, F | Crayton, P Jones, J Walter, K White, R Williams, R | Cooley, C Watson, B | Reed, J | Vikings, M |
| Unforgiven II | Warner, K Young, V | Barber, M Bradshaw, A Davenport, N Duckett, T Gore, F Morency, V Rhodes, D White, L | Colston, M Engram, B Mason, D | Gates, A | Crosby, M | Chargers, S |
| Steve's Stars | Brees, D Rivers, P | Jackson, S Jones, K Smith, K Stecker, A Ward, D Wright, J | Bennett, D Brown, R Burress, P Marshall, B Muhammad, M | Gonzalez, T | Brown, J | Ravens, B |